Tuesday, February 12, 2013

Stephen King's Guns: A Rebuttal

I asked my former co-blogger and wife Denise to review Stephen King's screed that is on sale for the Amazon Kindle. She read this so you don't have to. I think this rebuttal needs to be disseminated as widely as possible so feel free to use it with attribution of course. Stephen King is one of if not the most popular novelist in the world. A screed by him carries weight. Denise has done her hopefully not small part to counter this.

No links to this book. You can find it on the Amazon site if you want to find it. Stephen King has shown his even handedness by donating profits from this essay to the Brady Campaign. 

Denise has no plans to return to blogging at this time.


I've read much of Stephen King's work.  He is a great craftsman and he brings that skill to this piece, a quickie Kindle Single.  

The fact that he wrote the "book" fast shows.  He made at least one huge mistake.  He named the Newtown shooter as Ryan Lanza the first time he mentioned Newtown (he later correctly names Adam).  This was after describing how the press reacts to a mass shooting including getting the shooter's name wrong.  There are also irritating quirks like the use of "honey" to address readers.

Style and mistakes aside, King tries to add to the national dialog about gun violence.  The last section of this short work, lists policy ideas that might cut down on gun violence.  One notion is a ban on "assault weapons" but he loses his argument when he gets too cute by half, honey.

King justifies calling for such a ban by insulting owners of semi-automatics (a gun that fires one round per trigger pull).  He says that the owners only use these guns to fire as fast as they can while yelling yeehaw and getting horny.  I shoot often and own what might be called an assault weapon.  I have never fired as fast as I can twitch my finger.  I've never yelled yeehaw while shooting and I've never seen such behavior at gun ranges.  In fact, most people participating in rifle competitions today use variants of the AR-15.  The platform is highly accurate, stable, and has low recoil.  

Along with the assault weapon ban, King has two other policy ideas: universal background checks and bans on magazines holding more than ten rounds.  King's policy ideas will not work and I'll take them one at a time.  

Congress may pass some sort of enhanced background checks.  Depending on details, such a law really will not affect me much.  I tend to buy guns from federally licensed dealers who must check my  background even if they are selling guns at a gun show.  Criminals tend to buy guns on the street where there are no background checks.  Some mass shooters have bought their guns legally (Cho, Holmes) and were not in the system as "nucking futs" even though Cho should have been.  Others steal guns.

A magazine ban ignores the millions of magazines that already exist.  A magazine is a box with a spring and anyone with a 3D printer can print one.  Do we really want to try to outlaw 3D printers, springs, sheet metal, let alone the millions of magazines that people bought legally one year and become felons for owning the same box the next year?

King admits that an assault weapon ban probably will not happen. There is the problem of identifying just what is an assault weapon. There really is no such thing when you start getting into it. That's why the 1994 ban really did not ban much. King touts Australia's ban on them and pump action shotguns.(In other words, confiscating your grandfather's duck hunting gun.)The jury is not truly in on that gun ban. For one, there are still a lot of guns in Australia and other countries that have strong gun laws (see, http://reason.com/archives/2012/12/22/gun-restrictions-have-always-bred-defian/print). Also, crime has risen in Australia after the ban (see, http://www.ncpa.org/sub/dpd/index.php?Article_ID=17847). 

Finally King calls on gun owners to "urge Congress to do the right thing, and insists the NRA climb aboard...."  I own guns.  I am a former police officer.  I first shot a gun when I was 8 years old.  I was given a pump action .22 rifle for my 13th birthday.  I've owned guns for over 40 years and never put a hole in anyone (not even as a cop) or anything I was not willing to shoot.  I am a responsible gun owner.  

There are millions of gun owners who have never abused the right to own a gun.  They've never shot up a school, or stuck up a taxi driver.  Gun laws will only affect these responsible people.  Laws will not stop crime, and will not stop a mass shooter.  

Given this fact, why should I support Congress banning my guns or making it impossible to leave them to my children?  Why would I support a ban on magazines that might make me a felon?  Why would I support enhanced background checks when I don't know the details and don't believe they will work anyway?  Sorry Stephen, you haven't convinced this gun owner who has never once yelled "yeehaw" while shooting a semi-auto or any gun for that matter.


Relationship Counselling Chennai said...

Nice post , i hope everyone , will like your post

Windy Wilson said...

At best an expanded background check will have the same effect on violence that an annual breathalyzer test will have on drunk-driving-caused accidents. At worst the expanded background check will enable the government to go in a la Belgium and determine who the gun owners are and arrest them.

And the only person I've ever met who fired a semi-auto as fast as he could was my friend's 10 year old son, and that was really a .22lr lever action, and it was his first time with a firearm. He didn't shout anything, though, and we've all agreed that he has to buy his own ammo next time.

web lol said...

kul post

Yahoo mail problems said...

Very nice,,,Thanks for sharing..

Unknown said...

it make sense and lots of humor!
Heard about Discount Hardwood Flooring

Unknown said...

Thanks for sharing this i learn a lot to know our rights!
Heard about Asbestos Lawyer Beaumont

Unknown said...

Nice article, thanks for the information. It's very complete information http://awriter.org/rushessaycom/.

Unknown said...

Hello my name is Ngozi Okocha. A student of university of Nigeria. I find your work quite interesting. Please contact us at www.unn.edu.ng for more educational materials. Thank you

Unknown said...

nấm âm đạo
vô sinh nữ
rối loạn kinh nguyệt
viêm lộ tuyến cổ tử cung
khí hư ra nhiều
phòng khám phụ khoa
phòng khám Thiên Hòa

Minh An said...

tiểu buốt
tiểu rắt
tiểu ra máu
tiểu nhiều
phòng khám đa khoa thiên hòa
viêm tinh hoàn
Điều trị sùi mào gà
Chữa bệnh rận mu

Minh An said...

mụn dương vật
chữa bệnh sùi mào gà
sùi mào gà
mụn rộp sinh dục
rận mu
đau tinh hoàn
bệnh xã hội
phòng khám thiên hòa

Asif said...

I am really impressed by this wonderful stuff. I always prefer to read the quality content and this thing I found in you post.

KarlDeville said...

Thank you for taking the time and sharing this information with us. It was indeed very helpful and insightful while being straight forward and to the point.
www.mcdonaldsgutscheine.net/ | www.Startlr.com/ | www.SaludLimpia.com/

KarlDeville said...

Thank you for taking the time and sharing this information with us. It was indeed very helpful and insightful while being straight forward and to the point.
www.mcdonaldsgutscheine.net/ | www.Startlr.com/ | www.SaludLimpia.com/

Racing Games Top Free Games said...

Thanks for writing and sharing this article with us.
We needed such stuff.
From Team Traffic Racing

Minh An said...

i wan to Golf 3d

Freddi King said...

I really enjoyed reading this post. Thanks for sharing!

Nisha Burges said...

I barely know anything as it concerns Empowered Boost Male Enhancement, really. Well, I'm as honest as the day is long. I can't miss the fact this I, in practice, be for that opinion. At the very top of my list, I'd recommend looking into Testosterone Booster this evening. We'll begin by nailing down these writings bordering on Testosterone Booster. Very few amateurs understand this as soon as testosterone Booster can be a diamond in the rough. You wouldn't believe that anyway.

Iron Core Edge
Keto BodyTone
BitCoin Era Chile
Crypto Engine Reviews
Vital Keto Avis
OkoWatt Energy Saver
OxyBreath Pro Mask

Latest Reviews said...

Tech Gadgets is a large market. This essay is your unofficial guide to Tech Gadgets. This might be very a mystery for Tech Gadgets owners. If you follow these simple tips, you'll locate that you will get excited about your Tech Gadgets.. By virtue of what do masters run across certified Tech Gadgets objects? That is worth substantial sums. Everything I have done with Tech Gadgets has worked.

AOL Support Number
PowerVolt Energy Saver

Unknown said...

ucuz takipçi
ucuz takipçi
tiktok izlenme satın al
binance güvenilir mi
okex güvenilir mi
paribu güvenilir mi
bitexen güvenilir mi
coinbase güvenilir mi

Oros CBD Gummies said...

You’ll see a bunch of different forms of creatine on your supplement store’s shelves. In fact, for the novice, he has a separate section where elaborations on all the types of muscles have been furnished along with the tips to strengthen each individually. For the pro bodybuilders, he also shares some special tactics and strategies that would enable them for selecting the best poses at different fests and programmes.



KetoCore ACV Gummies said...

There is little doubt that you have to locate a modular Diet Pills is that it does not provide a link to Diet Pills. It doesn't matter if it's your own Weight Loss Gummies or somebody else's. You have to act within a short amount of time. Are you annoyed by that? Perhaps you have wondered why Keto Diet has captured the attention of so many counterparts. Keto Diet has caused it's share of fear and loathing. Doing that with Keto Diet now and worrying about it later is an eminently defensible strategy.